10 April 2018

You probably do this all the time, but you don’t even know it.

I’m talking about AC power calculations with P = V x I.

Technically, it works. But when you think about it, it shouldn’t. AC has constantly changing voltage and current over time – unlike DC.

So how on earth does it work?

Well, the short version is: RMS, or root mean square!

The long version involves a (simplified) explanation of AC power involving Watts, Volt-Amperes, and Power Factor.

But not to worry: At the end of the day, you can safely use P = V x I with AC, and you’ll still end up with a result that’s close enough for horseshoes!

Keep in mind that while P = Vrms x Irms is apparent power, you can still calculate real power using P = Vrms x Irms x cos ϕ, where ϕ is the phase angle between the current and voltage – and cos ϕ is just the power factor.

The usual problem with this approach is that very few gizmos will have a label or documentation specifying the power factor!

So, you can guess, or you can just do P = Vrms x Irms, get apparent power, and you’ll be close enough.

Finally, note that if you have two apparent power values for 2 different gizmos, you cannot just add those two apparent powers together – unless they have the exact same power factor.

Isn’t this FUN?! It just gets hairier and hairier…

But the bottom line is, do P = V x I and you’ll be close enough. Besides, that’s what you were doing anyway! 😉

EEK! #6 – AC Power, RMS, and VA vs W
Tagged on:                     

2 thoughts on “EEK! #6 – AC Power, RMS, and VA vs W

  • 11 April 2018 at 05:00
    Permalink

    A mechanical example which can provide some understanding of VARS is a swinging pendulum. A pendulum swings with significant velocity and gravitational force but uses negligible power. This is unlike sliding a brick along the floor, which requires real power (and will also scratch your floor.)

    At the bottom of the swing the pendulum velocity is highest but the force of gravity is perpendicular to the motion so is not affecting the velocity at that instant. There is maximum kinetic energy but minimum potential energy at the bottom of the swing.
    As the pendulum approaches the top of its swing, gravity opposes and slows the motion so kinetic energy is declining and potential energy is increasing.
    At the top of the swing the pendulum is momentarily stopped so it has maximum potential energy and minimum kinetic energy.
    As it begins to fall, the potential energy is decreasing and the kinetic energy is increasing.
    The swinging pendulum has significant “circulating” energy but negligible average power. The same is true if you connect (do not try this at home!) a high quality capacitor (this would be one with a low “dissipation factor”) to an AC voltage source. The Watts will be nearly zero but you will get significant circulating energy or VARS = Volt Ampere Reactive(s)

    Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.